it Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - Smudge-Proof Long Lasting Eyeliner Pencil (Brown) - Perfect for Everyday Makeup & Special Occasions

Similar to other gel eyeliners I have tried but a little less expensive. The last gel eyeliner I tried and was sold on was Marc Jacobs who had a set of like 4 or 5 travel sized pencils. I really liked those, but they were a bit on the pricey side. This one goes on easily and doesn't seem to cause raccoon eyes mid-day. I'd say it's almost comparable to the Marc Jacobs eyeliner, although I really liked one of the brown shades offered by that line better. Pleased with purchase so far, but have not tried sharpening yet so we'll see how that goes!I really love this eyeliner - my ONLY problem is how much work it is to get it off. Sometimes it'll rip out my eye lashes when I'm trying to get everything off of it. It is the only eyeliner I've had that stays put and the color lasts all day without drooping down onto my eye lids. I really love it - if only it wouldn't dry onto my lashes so much, I'd be a regular user of it.This item has stopped being produced for some reason so I bought two on here to stock up. They are fabulous and I hope the company starts manufacturing them again.Maybe it's because I have old eyelids, but I didn't find this to be "no-tug" at all. In fact, I had such a hard time getting it to line my eyes that I only tried it once and now it is banned to the "bought it, didn't like it, but I probably shouldn't throw it away" drawer. I've been using a gel pencil which I love but it has to be sharpened constantly so it wears down pretty fast. I thought that since this is very thin AND gel it would work perfectly. It didn't work for me. It may work very well and tug-free for those with thicker eyelids.Value for money and it goes on smoothly really is a no tug eyeliner have been using it for a whileThis is my go-to eyeliner. It stays put all day and comes off easily when you’re ready to remove it.very nice stays on even when I sweat. I barely look at myself since I have started to use the IT gel eyeliner, because it does not run. The brown is a good color for those who are more autumn "color". We have a bit of yellow in our skin so black does not become us, brown and dark blue is our "black". I would highly suggest this to anyone.This is one of the only liners that glider easily on the inside lid and stays all day!